Contracting with a company - check for director authority
A recent High Court judgment reminds us once again of how important it is, when dealing with a company, to check that whichever director/s you are dealing with is/are fully authorised to bind the company.
R3.8m in claims attacked
- A liquidation application was launched against a property developing company with 3 directors,
- The applicant creditor was owed some R3.8m in loan and suretyship claims,
- Its problem was that the suretyship and loan agreements had been signed by only one of the directors of the property company, with the knowledge and approval of the second director but not of the third,
- The third director (acting as trustee of a creditor trust) opposed the liquidation application on the grounds that the first and second directors had acted without authority. He argued that the creditor had no claim against the company, and therefore had no standing to liquidate it,
- The Court found on the facts that the creditor had failed to prove that the first and second directors had acted with authority. Nor had it proved that they were held out as being persons authorised to manage the company's affairs. Thus it could not enforce any claim, and the liquidation order was refused.
So, how do you prove authority?
You must firstly show that you were dealing with someone who had either actual or apparent (often called "ostensible") authority to contract with you. You can't enforce your claim if you can't prove authority!
As a rule you are allowed to assume that the board of directors and any managing director have the necessary authority. The same doesn't generally apply to any ordinary director or employee, except perhaps to the extent that they hold an executive position (financial director or branch manager perhaps) which suggests that they have authority "usual to that type of position". Of course you can't make any assumptions at all if you actually knew, or should have known or suspected, that the director or employee was acting outside his/her powers and authority.
No wriggle room
To complicate matters (sorry, but this is important and to your advantage) what happens if a company tries to wriggle out of its contract with you on the basis that, unknown to you, the director had breached some internal company procedure? Since usually only insiders will know about a company's internal policies, it would be highly unfair to you if that were allowed.
To protect you, our law says that, once you have proved actual or apparent authority as above, you can then assume that all the company's internal rules and policies have been complied with. Out of interest, if you ever hear lawyers earnestly and learnedly debating "The Turquand Rule", this is what they are talking about.
Beware - our law on this is both complex and fraught with grey areas, and the notes above are just a summary of some general legal principles. Insist on directors you contract with producing written proof of authority (a formal company resolution to start with) and take legal advice on your particular circumstances!
FEATURED PAGESCost Calculators
Calculate your approximate transfer costs together with estimated registration fees and transfer duty with our Transfer Cost Calculator; Bond Cost Calculator and Bond Repayment Calculator. (NOTE - this is best viewed in Chrome or the latest version of IE)Contact us
Click above for our contact details and contact us for any additional information or enquiries.Goldberg & de Villiers Inc.
Are you searching for legal service from experienced professionals who strike the much-needed balance between innovation and tradition, and who will put your needs first? At Goldberg & de Villiers Inc, we proudly offer our clients that state-of-the-art, up to date approach to business and legal services, whilst always keeping our clients' specific needs as our main focus. With us, experience and innovation go hand in hand, so clients feel comfortable entrusting their business to the firm - knowing the team can offer them the best of both worlds.
It is this unique combination of trusted experience and modern flexibility that makes Goldberg & de Villiers Inc the choice of such a variety of discerning clients, from one-man businesses to multinational listed companies. Since our inception in 1933, our commitment to personal service, practical advice and tailor-made proactive solutions has earned us a stellar reputation in our field.
The South African Weather Services on Saturday morning again warned that very hot weather conditions and high discomfort levels are expected in most parts of the Eastern Cape throughout the day. Veld Fire Conditions are expected over the...
Public hearings on the Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership...
The South African National Roads Agency SOC Ltd (SANRAL)...
All eyes are on the next move from President Jacob...
A 31-year-old man is expected in court soon after he was...
A surprise donation by Airports Company of South Africa...
The sprint to the end of the year and the extended holidays...
The proposed construction of a Nuclear Power...
The South African Weather Services office in Port Elizabeth...
Two Nigerian nationals, aged between 37 and 43 years old...
- Very hot and uncomfortable weather conditions expected over Eastern Cape
- Zuma's refusal to quit puts South Africa's economy on an even weaker footing
- ANC-led march demands better service delivery from Nelson Mandela Bay’s DA-led coalition
- Two Nigerian nationals busted with drugs worth R630 000 in Grahamstown
- Thyspunt Nuclear Forum calls for speedy process at Thyspunt so locals can get jobs